On the issue of splicing/editing for recording musicians: Musician or not - please respond with comments. Which opinion do you carry....
A) The Glenn Gould mentality profesionally molded into the politicism of Malcolm X: Artistic perfection by any means necessary, even in the case where it might imply and even necessitate a certain amount of sacrificial integrity. In short, the mentality revolves around the following premise. Artistic perfection is an impossible dream, but to strive for it is a perpetual necessity, so why should I ignore the technical unlimitation that can help me take a step forward? Integrity is a small price to pay for near-perfection; at least certainly on a technical level.
B) The Heifetz/Rubinstein way mentality. Art and music are man-made creations which, hence, are and should be limited by the stench of man's limitations, if not only for the sake of integrity. Integrity is not only a fundamental basis for art and music, it is an implicit inclusion in the very meaning of the word! To ignore it or compromise it would be diminishing your character as a musician - your artistic self would be an artificial joke. Something unreal - only possible with high-tech technology. What if somebody asks you to play what you recorded? To not be able to do it is hideously disgusting and humorous. You make me want to swallow my own vomit.
C) Splicing isn't sacrificing integrity. (wtf?)
D) You're dumb.
Inspired simultaneously and erratically by the blog thoughts of both Stanley Lee and Ned Rorem.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2003
(146)
-
▼
January
(37)
- I smoked a grand total of 37 cigarettes today. May...
- Good Forward from Jeff: jm2cal: The most unfair t...
- Lifted from a progressive Yale leaflet: "It is th...
- Congratulations to my homeboy Eugene, on his recen...
- "Without music, life would be a mistake." -Friedri...
- I've been painfully busy lately. I can't think str...
- More to follow.... http://www.cnn.com/2003/US/Wes...
- Just a bit of weather news: It's colder in New Hav...
- Sorry, guys. I've been busy lately. peterlsb (12...
- "The statistics on sanity are that one out of ever...
- Five-dollar reference: Her: If I told you, "don't...
- For all you nerdy pianists out there. If you find ...
- It's been a long time since I've been so infuriate...
- Lately, I have been at the piano non-stop - please...
- Check out Stan's new ride yo: http://cgi.ebay.co...
- We've finally hit rock bottom with Bush: http://...
- Congratulations to my old, long-lost homeboy, Lynz...
- Taken from Stan's blog: will everybody on the inte...
- Being at Yale, I had almost forgotten what it was ...
- Happy Birthday and rest in peace, Sean Sanderson. ...
- Perhaps this is the real reason classical music is...
- The death penalty is evil and racist. Props to Rep...
- Playlist, to be accomplished before March 1st. B...
- Classical musicians should never be allowed to rap...
- As a follow up to the last post: Think about a wor...
- On the issue of splicing/editing for recording mus...
- There is a new best blog out there which is not re...
- I just finished Red Dragon - definitely one of the...
- For those who believe that blogging is for the nar...
- Tyler, the genius that he is, has found a perfect ...
- I love fobs. chink15 (7:44:35 PM): have you had ...
- If you never knew HT and Amir from Berkeley, you m...
- An excerpt of an essay written by my 15-year old s...
- I'm back now. Thrown unwillingly from a paradise o...
- My resume of rumbles and public displays of anger ...
- If you haven't already, please take the time to re...
- In a few days, I'll be forcefully removed from par...
-
▼
January
(37)
No comments:
Post a Comment